Thursday, April 9, 2009

New Zealand's Problem With Crime


Across the world New Zealand is considered to be a clean and green country. A country where a comfortable lifestyle can be easily obtained and a country where it is safe to raise a family. But lately our crime rate appears to be increasing. This apparent increase has led to my interest on the topic and my desire to discover an underlying cause. My thoughts have always been: "New Zealand - a first world country, relatively safe . . . " However, my thoughts on the general safety of New Zealand are still being shaped as I look more closely into the causes and effects of this socio-political topic. I am particularly interested in researching youth crime as opposed to general crime as it is the young people who will lead us into the future.
Did you know that with approximately 70 major gangs, New Zealand has the largest number of gangs per capita in the world? When I first discovered this fact, I was shocked. Perhaps this is one of the underlying causes as to our increasing crime rate.

Street gangs have not always existed in New Zealand. In fact, real street gangs only came into existance around the time of the 1950s and appear to have followed in the footsteps of well-known American gangs such as the Crips. The members of the first street gangs founded around the time of the 1950s were typically older than those involved in youth gangs today. In fact, youth gangs are only fairly recent and appear to be on the rise. But why, you may ask, are youth gangs on the rise when our quality of life in New Zealand appears to be improving.

Well, why do people join gangs in the first place? There are many reasons as to why one may join a gang. I believe that the key reasons relate to poverty and one's upbringing. The majority of our gangs exist in the poorer areas of New Zealand as a method of making money through drugs, robberies, money laundering, plus other forms of criminal activity. Many young people living in our poorer areas experience a lack of education which in turn may lead to a lack of job opportunities. For these people, involvement in a gang may be seen as a successful money making method. However, I feel there is another key factor behind gang involvement that relates indirectly to poverty. In poorer areas, quality of life is not as high and parents tend to work longer hours. As a result, younger family members may discover a sense of belonging in a particular gang as opposed to family. Have you ever heard of the saying "POWER IN NUMBERS"? I believe that this saying applies to gangs for more than one reason. Not only due to the fact that gangs continue because of the fear they induce, but also because gang members gain a sense of importance and belonging, which may be lacking due to the absence of a strong family bond, through their accomplishments with the gang. Members are often granted praise from other members and may even be rewarded with a patch for committing a particular crime.

Another key cause I believe to exist is that of one's upbringing. Before the 1950s, street gangs were quite rare thus youth did not grow up with any form of gang influence. However, when the first real street gangs were established, the younger generations for the first time began to witness gang involvement as a part of life. For the first time younger people were being influenced by older street gang members who may have been related. As gang involvement and influence in New Zealand began to increase, it slowly emerged as a way of life for certain communities and more of the young people in these communities started to become involved in gangs at a much younger age until the idea of entrapment began to emerge. Many developed the idea that this way of life was the only way and it is difficult to filter a belief, that has been passed down from generation to generation, out of a society. I believe that these concepts may be part of the answer as to why youth gangs are on the rise.

However, not all gangs consist solely of males. In the last few years New Zealand has experienced a rise in what is termed "girl gangs". However, such 'girl gangs' have not always existed. In fact, up until not so long ago, females were considered to be accessories for male gangs. Now, they are forming their own gangs and can be just as malicious as their male gang counterparts. I was intrigued to discover the reasons for this drastic increase over the past 10 years. I found the reasons in statistics. It seems that females join gangs for different reasons to males. The majority of females who join gangs have been exposed to gangs from a young age and most have been physically or sexually abused. It seems that females join gangs as a way of protection. They may seek refuge in other members who have had similar experiences or they may feel less vulnerable within a larger group. As gang numbers increase, it is likely that more female gangs will emerge as a method of protection.

However, youth gangs do not account for all youth crime in New Zealand, just the majority of it. Take tagging for example. And although most would argue that tagging is only a minor part of youth crime, it usually precedes or accompanies other acts of violent crime. Tagging is termed property damage and is a cause for concern because it is often the teenagers who begin with tagging that go on to commit more serious crimes later on. Some would argue that tagging is a 'non-violent' way of testing the boundaries of what is morally acceptable and is just the beginning of more violence to come. What about the recent increase in violent girl fights, like the ones that are frequently posted on YouTube? While it is important that we focus on the more dangerous crimes committed by youth in New Zealand that create a cause for concern, it is also important that we don't overlook the acts termed 'minor' as they may help us to prevent more serious crimes. It is essential that we look into every aspect of youth crime because surely they are all intertwined.

So what about the seriously haunting crimes such as murder and various attacks? Surely there must be some trends indicating who is likely to carry out such acts. I have always been intrigued to discover what shapes a serial killer, or just a killer for that matter. What causes a young person to carry out murder?

Take Bailey Junior Kurariki for example, the youngest person in New Zealand to be convicted of manslaughter. He was involved in the killing of pizza delivery man, Michael Choy, in Christchurch in 2001. Bailey Junior Kurariki, also known as BJ, is termed New Zealand's youngest killer at the age of 12. I was intrigued to discover who else, if anybody, was involved in the carrying out of this haunting murder. When I discovered the answers, I cannot say I was surprised. A group of six youths, including BJ, were responsible for this cruel act of injustice with the primary purpose being to make a few extra dollars. BJ was the youngest at only 12 with the oldest being a mere 17. One of the key factors leading to BJ's participation in the murder was his eagerness to please those older than himself. Through this case we can learn about some of the dynamics that operate within a youth gang. Despite the fact that this group may not have seen themselves as a typical 'patch gang', the dynamics within resemble very closely a typical youth gang.

I believe that the recent increase in youth crime is linked primarily to gang involvement but is also a result of our everchanging society, not only within New Zealand, but throughout the world. Not all youth crime can be accounted for by gangs, but it seems that the majority of it can be. With the highest number of gangs per capita in the world comes the necessity to find solutions to the causes of such statistics. However, it is difficult to change communities that have operated in such a way for decades, but if we allow it to continue for too long it might just be too late.

22 comments:

  1. I say probably the greatest concern we should have—and I know this is how the police feel about it—is not the gangs who are wearing patches on the streets and who are very visible in committing street crime but, rather, the gangs who we do not see and who are heavily involved in drug trafficking and money-laundering, etc. What are your thoughts on the matter.

    ReplyDelete
  2. As a study abroad student, I think I only experience all the good things about New Zealand. That New Zealand is not that green and environmentally friendly as I always thought and as it is said to be is another story… Every day in the morning when having breakfast, I watch the news, on the one hand to improve my English but on the other one also to know what’s going on in the world - and in New Zealand. However, maybe I don’t watch the news that seriously. I do not have any idea what’s “really” going on in New Zealand and therefore, living here is not ‘real’ everyday life for me. I definitely think of this country to be a safe and wonderful country to live.
    It is only two things that reminded me that New Zealand is a country with problems as every other state - including criminality. Some day in one of the first weeks I have been in Auckland, a guy addressed himself to me near the AUT; he was from Amnesty International. He asked me what in my opinion the biggest crime issue in New Zealand is. I did not know, so he told me that it is domestic violence… In Germany, once I watched a documentary about New Zealand. Apart from all the awesome things - the landscape, the people and everything - also ‘gangs’ have been mentioned, especially Maori gangs. I am really looking forward to your essay and to learn something about this issue. Maybe you can include something on Maori gangs.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think its kinda shocking to see the rise of Youth Crime in NZ these days? Did you watch 60 minues on Monday? Aparently females are becoming more like men forming their own gangs. Do you think part of being in a gang is for protection?

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hey, this is a very interesting topic and is something that is increasing within the younger generation. I think that the reason for the increase of gangs has a huge affect on how these children are treated at home? I have just recently finished high school and there were quite a few little gangs being formed. I’m guessing, a reason for this is to be cool and follow other big gangs. Or maybe it is to have a sense of belonging and gain a feeling of being safe around the people they call friends. I watched a documentary a while back about the gang life in Otara. The majority of the gang members were between 17-25 years old and they were all of Polynesian descent. I feel that living in South Auckland children are at higher risk and are being more exposed to the gang life. And seeing this around them 24/7, they should start to feel that this is second nature to them e.g. acting in such ways and wearing such colours just to name a few. I have also seen many campaigns trying to prevent gangs but maybe the only reason why these people join one is to have a stronger sense of belonging?

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi guys thankyou for your comments. Haitian - I agree with you in that gangs who are involved in money laundering and drug trafficking behind the scenes are a major concern because police are unable to keep tabs on what is going on which is potentially very dangerous. But I also feel that well-known street gangs are equally as dangerous. Take the Mongrel Mob or Black Power for example. Although they are well-known, by both the police and the general public, they are still a major threat to all of society.
    Mohnkuchen - you said that the documentary you watched in Germany mentioned Maori gangs in particular. Well, some gangs recruit members regardless of their ethnicity such as the Mongrel Mob (whose members are predominantly Maori or of Pacific Island descent) while others recruit members of a specific ethnicity such as Black Power (a Maori gang). Did the documentary mention any specific gangs? I would be interested to hear how the rest of the world perceives New Zealand gangs.
    NiouJas - I did watch 60 Minutes last Monday. I thought it was really interesting to hear the viewpoints of some ex - girl gang members. From what I can gather females are definitely becoming more violent like their male gang counterparts. The girls who were interviewed seemed to be proud of their gang achievements and viewed their male gang counterparts as competition. In fact, they felt that the girls were tougher and more intelligent when it came to crime. But I thought the girl who was trying to get her life back on track was really admirable. The girls all said that the primary reason for their involvement in a gang was protection. Each had grown up with gang influence and most had been abused at some stage. I believe that by joining a girl gang they gained a sense of protection in that they believed they could fight back. What do you think?
    Oriana - as I mentioned before I definitely think that youth are joining gangs these days in order to experience a sense of belonging (as well as protection) and also because they have grown up witnessing this kind of lifestyle. I guess that many of the youth aspire to become as 'influential' as some of the more predominant gangs. Home life definitely has a huge effect as most gang members have been abused. I just think it is really sad that youth crime is increasing in New Zealand as I'm sure you guys are too. Thanks for your feedback.
    Keep commenting :-)

    ReplyDelete
  6. Very well-written article, Natalie!

    haitian,
    in my opinion, we should be concerned about ALL kinds of gangs. The fact that these (youth) gangs are connected with the increasing crime rate proves that something is wrong in our society - and that we have to tackle with this problem. However, of course, you are right with your statement that some groups are more dangerous than others, that hidden criminality might be more serious than the evident.
    About the reasons for gang membership: Like all of you guys, I also believe that the main reason especially for youth gangs is a lack of the sense of belonging somewhere, a lack of family. Human beings have a need to be social and esteemed. In our faster and faster ever-changing world, where moral and virtue seem to have completely disappeared, this might be really hard. Therefore, it is no wonder that some people seek refuge or even ‘love’ in a community like a gang, which replaces a family that doesn’t exist.

    Natalie,
    in the Internet, I found a commentary based on the documentary I mentioned before. In the report, they especially talk about the Mongrel Mob. The crew was allowed to participate and even film a wedding. I was again confused by the appearance of the gang; they look like rocker… Moreover, the report talks about the Māori situation, that they fight for compensation for the injustice they had to suffer from during colonial times. It is mentioned that in December 2008, the application period expired and that the Mongrel Mob now is waiting and hoping to be attributed with money. The gang made a statement like the following, which really affected me: They reminded the crew that they became the way they are today only because Pākehā treated once them so badly...
    http://www.zdf.de/ZDFmediathek/content/Unterwegs_in_Neuseeland/658940

    ReplyDelete
  7. I think this is horrible.
    The ages of children in gangs is gradually getting younger and younger, how young will they be in our childrens generation?
    I agree that the gangs are mostly in poorer areas, but they are beginning to form in places that up until recently have been safe. This is very worrying.
    Even though most people think that graffiti is not a big deal, i agree with you and think that it can be the beginning of much more serious crimes.
    I CANNOT BELIEVE THAT BOY KILLED SOMEONE WHEN HE WAS ONLY 12! what is the world coming to?!
    I think that something needs to be done to stop all of this crime, any ideas?

    ReplyDelete
  8. That is what happens when police are weak, the government is useless and major media are helping to promote gang culture. Mongrel Mob, Head Hunters, Black Power, we hear about them all the time, from newspapers, radios, TV. We know they do drugs, they have guns, but does the government do anything about it? No, they legalize the gang culture.

    In some countries, you will be charge as soon as you mention you are within a gang, you will be in police file for life, but here in New Zealand even for the current gang members, you can appear on national TV, you can get interviews, instead of criminals they are treat like some kind of celebrities.

    We keep criminals in their houses because our prisons are overflows; we don’t build new prisons because it will cost millions of dollars. These reasons are ridiculous, but we still accepting them, so don’t worry if you ran someone over, all you getting is 3 months in your sofa. How could all of these stop our children joining gangs?

    ReplyDelete
  9. Hi guys thankyou for your comments. Mohnkuchen - thankyou for posting that URL. I will definitely take a closer look. I find it interesting what you mentioned about the belief held by some of the Maori gangs shown in the documentary regarding gang origin being a consequence of treatment by Pakeha in the past. I personally believe that the Maori have already been compensated for any injustice suffered. I wonder whether this is really their primary reason for gang involvement. Perhaps members of such gangs feel that others will view them as weak for admitting that their gang involvement is primarily a result of wanting to belong. Perhaps New Zealand gangs attempt to convince outsiders of this in order to cover up the truth, or maybe even to convince themselves that their involvement is not due to a feeling of vulnerability. What do you feel about this? Cherushii - I also feel that urgent action needs to be taken. Did you guys hear about the law that was passed last night in government regarding the ban of gang patches in Wanganui? If you haven't heard, a law has been passed regarding the wearing of gang patches in Wanganui. The public display of symbols or colours affiliated with any gang, such as the Mongrel Mob, has been made illegal. The police in Wanganui now have the power to arrest gang members who display patches. I personally feel that this is a step forward in dealing with gangs and crime here in NZ. Even though this law only applies to Wanganui, Michael Laws (the mayor of Wanganui) is confident that other areas throughout NZ will follow. This law could possibly be the beginning of change. What do you guys think about this?

    ReplyDelete
  10. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  11. hey there, sorry i hadn't looked at the comment that you had posted up. Yay!something is being doen about these gang members. Finally they are taking action towards violence. I definately find this a step towards decreasing the crime rate, i know it's only in one area so far but hopefully soon this law will be taken up by other areas of NZ especially South Auckland:)

    ReplyDelete
  12. I think this is one of the interesting topic! And also SHOCKING too!! I knew that NZ youth crime has been increasing these days.. I’m so sad about Bailey Junior kurariki. Did he really died by pizza delivery man? That is so scary. I experienced NZ gang with my brother once. They were hanging at the park.. more than 10 people? So scary.. and do you know few years ago, in Australia, there was a crime at convenience store, a high school student killed an asian high school student? However~ It was interesting Natalie!

    ReplyDelete
  13. Natalie,
    unfortunately, the link is a German one, so I’m afraid that you won’t understand anything. However, I already told you the most important facts =) – No, I didn’t want to say that the injustice Maori people suffered from in the past is their primary reason for gang involvement. First I would like to state that in my opinion, the Maori cannot “really” be compensated for what happened in the past… I think what they meant in the documentary is that what was then still has an influence on what is today… By the way - do you know how many gangs are Maori gangs??
    I’m afraid that I don’t know enough about the topic; I cannot really discuss the topic based on facts. I don’t want to speculate. However, what I know is that the family structure of a Maori family is different from that one of European origin. Therefore, especially for gangs with Maori members the reason of “belonging” makes sense. In my view, it is because of the history that their family boundaries might develop to a gang - or is this completely nonsense??

    Concerning the law regarding the ban of gang patches in Wanganui: at least THIS is completely nonsense! It’s not that you want to arrest people because they wear patches or because they are in a gang - you want people to be arrested because of drug smuggling, money laundering and because of murder! The law is a mere drop in the ocean, it will never achieve anything.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Hey people and particulary Natalie, I want your opinions on this, Do you think video games and those R16/R18 movies are part of the influence on Youth Crime? I've seen a few documentries on Youth Crime not in just NZ but overseas particulary USA. It seems USA in a way is a big influence on Youth Crimes (no offence to anyone) as for BJ's case I think peer pressure is involved. I kinda have a perspective on this since I'm taking psychology. The way people in gangs behave is influenced by their envoironment. Think about it they're always surrounded by violence in a way it affects the way they behave.

    Correct me if I'm wrong XDD

    ReplyDelete
  15. Hi there. Mohnkuchen - you bring up a really good point there about the structure of the Maori family being different from that of the European family. The Maori family has always revolved around extended family as well as immediate family. These days it seems that the role of the extended family is diminishing and perhaps this traditional structure is slowly falling apart. Perhaps this is part of the reason for seeking a sense of belonging within a gang. It may be a way to reach out to those who are not necessarily immediate family but act as an 'extended family'. What do you think? By the way, I don't actually know how many gangs are Maori. But from what I have read I would say that a fair percentage of them are, but definitely not all.
    You guys definitely have a wide variety of views regarding the new law that was passed only a couple of days ago. I agree with you Oriana in that this is a step in the right direction. Like you I hope that this law will eventually be established in South Auckland as this is most probably the worst area in New Zealand for gangs and violence.

    Mohnkuchen - this law only passed narrowly through parliament which means that many people, like you, disagree with the idea. Many argue that the law violates one's freedom. However, those who are for the law argue, as Michael Laws does, that this is a case of the greater good of the community overriding freedom. I personally feel that we have to start somewhere in an attempt to control gangs and crime so why not give this law a fair chance? The purpose of this law is to prevent gangs from intimidating locals. Prior to the law, members of gangs such as the Mongrel Mob and Black Power had the right to roam the streets, intimidating locals. But now they will be arrested if seen to be doing this. Surely this is a start? In addition this may reduce the number of youth joining larger and more prominent gangs as members will have less of a chance to roam the streets recruiting younger members. It is only a very small step but as I said earlier we have to start somewhere. Does anyone have any other ideas as to what could realistically be done? I would be interested to hear.

    NiouJas - I agree with you in that gangs are influenced by their environment. For example, poverty and violence are definitely contributing factors. America is definitely a big influence on gang culture here in NZ. As I mentioned earlier in my blog, many New Zealand gangs have followed in the footsteps of well-known American gangs such as the Bloods and the Crips. I'm not too sure about the idea that violent video games are part of it though. Obviously video games have emerged only in the past generation and seem to have become more of an issue as the rate of youth crime continues to increase. I sometimes wonder whether this is just a convenient excuse for some. But sure, it may play a minor role. Have you been learning about gang culture in psychology? If you have I would be interested to hear more.

    ReplyDelete
  16. I haven't been though I wish I did:P It's just someting I found alarming. Well more like my little cousin who just turned 14 is now playing R16 and R18 games yet my aunty and uncle doesn't give a damn!!! I think Dennis mentioned that one's behaviour is influenced by the surrounding. They behave according to the environment.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Remember this "Bored people do stupid things"

    ReplyDelete
  18. I think you got a good point about it =)

    ReplyDelete
  19. hey check out these links they might be a little helpful :)

    http://www.3news.co.nz/Video/Top-judge-criticises-Govts-plans-for-youth-offenders/tabid/370/articleID/103965/cat/41/Default.aspx

    http://www.3news.co.nz/Video/National/tabid/309/articleID/103125/cat/100/Default.aspx#video

    http://www.3news.co.nz/Wanganui-gang-patch-bill-passes-62-59/tabid/368/articleID/102971/cat/41/Default.aspx

    hope this helps a little aha

    ReplyDelete
  20. HI
    Well written Natalie
    Wow this issue really scares me as cherushii said the age of offenders is gradually getting younger! Somthing needs to be done. I agree with
    NiouJas people are influenced by their environment and bored people do stupid things. Having to grow up in violent ganglike conditions children suffer and tend to see no other alternative from the life they have already and follow in their parents footsteps. It is amazing what children unwittingly pick up fromt their parents.
    My biggest fear when i think of youth crime and the durastic rate that it is increaseing is the thought of what it is going to be like in the near future for the next generation, my children. These current youth offenders are the generation to lead us forward. Instead of positiveness from them we see crime.
    Crime and youth gangs do seem the most common in the poorer parts of the country. Lack of money seems to be a large contributing motive.
    I count myself very lucky for having my upbringing where crime for a few extra dollars was never a neccesity. I pity these people as they can never seem to find a way out. It is a vicous cycle. Growing up and seeing your parents commit crime to feed the family and seeing no other way to not end up like your parents. Crime seems to be bred into thesse youths. Something needs to be done to stop the forming of gangs but something more also needs to be done to help people in these situations to form another way of life. I commend the new Whanganui laws!

    ReplyDelete
  21. Hey Oriana. Thankyou for posting those links. I have had a good look at each of them. I take it you are following the news regarding the new law? It seems to be quite topical at the moment, the issue of youth crime seems to have been on the news quite a bit recently. It seems that the government have finally realised the necessity of dealing with our increasing crime rate. Not only has the law that bans all gang insignia been passed in Wanganui but the government are planning to lower the age at which youth offenders can be punished to 12. In addition, the law would allow harsher sentencing for youth. I totally agree with the idea. It's a start in dealing with our youth offenders don't you think?

    Regarding the law that bans all patch insignia: I was shocked when I looked at the last link you posted. Michael Bott, the lawyer of human rights, stated that: "the law essentially punishes one for belonging to a group and expressing the identity of the group." Come on! How PC is this? New Zealand seems to be becoming more PC by the day and it is obviously not working as can be seen through our frightening crime statistics. Political correctness is supposed to protect the rights of people, yet it seems to actually be disregarding the rights of decent citizens. As Michael Laws stated: "the rights of the greater community come before the rights of gang members." I totally agree. What do you guys think? I would be interested to hear your views.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Taking care of upholstery is one of the easiest household chores. Still there are many housewives who do not know how to clean their furniture covers properly, which causes damages to the upholstery.

    removals London | moving company London

    ReplyDelete